Why critics want it stopped
Opponents argue that the story frames stalking, coercion and sexual violence romantically, and that film could amplify that framing through music, lighting, performance and marketing.
Read about the petition →The Haunting Adeline movie debate
This is not a campaign for or against the film. It is a place to understand why the announcement produced such a strong reaction before a creative team was even named.
Where do you stand?
Choose your position
An informal reader prompt, not a scientific poll. Your answer remains on this device.
Why supporters want it made
Supporters distinguish adult fantasy from real-life approval and argue that difficult fiction should not be cancelled before a screenplay, rating or director exists.
Read the full explainer →Why many people are undecided
They support adaptation, but want clearer agency, stronger consequences, honest adult marketing and careful handling of consent.
What responsible adaptation means →Editorial standard
Disagreement without rage bait
We separate confirmed facts from rumours, represent opposing arguments fairly and distinguish depiction from endorsement. Enjoying a book is not proof of someone's real-world values; criticising it is not censorship.
Follow every update
Subscribe without giving us your email
Use the RSS feed for new articles and material movie developments.